• Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Twitter

The Weekday Kitchen

The Weekday Kitchen

  • The Weekday Kitchen
  • Home
  • Random Musings
  • What I’m Cooking
  • Things I Love
  • About

Bahama Mama Copycat Recipe

June 28, 2020 by Angela 3 Comments

Bahama Mama Sausages

I get homesick sometimes. When that happens I like to make myself a treat of some kind of food that I can’t get locally. That might be Cincinnati Chili, or Frisch’s Tartar Sauce on a big old burger, or White Castle inspired sliders.

One other thing I really miss is Schmidt’s Sausage Bahama Mama’s. Schmidt’s is an amazing restaurant in the German Village in Columbus, Ohio. If you’re in the area go there. Or you can go to Oktoberfest Zinzinnati and have a Bahama Mama there. And also a cream puff as big as your head! And ps for my Wisconsin peeps, they make the cream puffs the right way, with custard, not whipped cream. I’m going to run now.

You can surely order the sausages from Schmidt’s for delivery, but be prepared to take out a second to pay for them (and the shipping). I’m cheap so I decided to make them. This is my second attempt.

Because I’m not a sausage maker on the regular (though I did learn how to in home ec in high school. That just shows you how old I am), I sought out the Googles for a place to start. I ran across this thread on smoked meat forums, and these people seemed to know their stuff. The first time I followed eDJs spicing scheme for my spicing, but I did a more coarse grind. The spicing was amazing, but the texture wasn’t quite what I was looking for (though they were delicious!)

This time I followed curious aardvark’s recipe pretty much to a T including the instructions, and the texture was spot on, though my husband and I recalled that the Bahama Mama was just a bit spicier.

The spicing. I didn’t have hot paprika, and that probably made a difference. I used smoked paprika.

First round of grinding for the pork, coarse grind.

Meaty.

Pork after the second round of grinding.

Pork, beef, spices and liquid. Here’s where I diverted from curious aardvark. I found a Leinenkugel’s Creamy Dark in the garage and used the heck out of that instead of water. Because why use water when you have beer?

And I mixed the crap out of it. What you’re going for here is some emulsification of the fats and liquid. That contributes to the dense and homogeneous texture in a sausage or hot dog.

The meats. After it’s beat. I put in the refrigerator overnight.

The next day, I stuffed them. This is a two-man operation unless you have a dedicated sausage maker. These LEM pre-tubed hog casings make it a bit easier. You’re going to want to soak these in cold water before using and I’m going to warn you, they smell. I get it that some people object to the smell, but folks…think about what they are. Regardless, I wouldn’t use any synthetic or casein casing. It just wouldn’t give you the right *snap*, in my opinion.

5 pounds of sausages. I’m not going to lie to you, this was a complete pain due to how glue-y the texture is on these but it’s totally worth it.

And make into links. Check out a video on how to do this because clearly I’m not the authority (and I muddled my way though it. Inconsistently as you can see).

Then I poached them in water, and gave them a cold water bath as curious aardvark suggested. My husband cold smoke them over hickory for about 2 hours. We use a Masterbuilt Smoker and love it, though people will tell you it’s not authentic. And I suppose it isn’t but it works and it’s easy.

And grilled. The snap was amazing. Next time I will kick the spicing up just a bit but the texture was perfect on these!

I served them with some homemade buns and homemade spicy brown mustard. They were very good and well worth the effort!

Bahama Mama Sausages
Print Recipe
No ratings yet

Copycat Bahama Mama Sausages

Copycat Bahama Mama Sausages with instructions for sausage making at home
Course: Main Course
Cuisine: American
Servings: 8

Ingredients

  • 3 lb fatty pork shoulder
  • 2 lb cheap beef
  • 1 cup ice cold water I used beer.
  • 1 cup skimmed milk powder I used whole milk powder because that's what I had on hand.
  • 6 good tsp salt
  • 5 tsp paprika I would also add 1/2 teaspoon cayenne next time.
  • 4 tsp sugar
  • 2 tsp hot mustard powder
  • 5 gm cure #1

Instructions

  • See written instructions.

Filed Under: What I'm Cooking

This post contains affiliate links. If you click the links and make a purchase, I do get a small commission from the sale of the product. It does not impact the purchase price to you. I do not recommend products I have not used, ever. Thank you for your support!

Independent Watkins Consultant

Interested in winning free Watkins products? Click here.

Interested in purchasing Watkins products? Click here.

Interested in a respected home business of your own? Click here.

Meatball Sub Casserole
King Arthur Flour Buttery Hot Dog Buns

Comments

  1. Kathy Jameyson says

    July 31, 2022 at 2:05 pm

    What kind of grind do you do with the pork on the second round?. What kind of beef did you use? Hamburger? Round?

    Reply
    • Angela says

      August 4, 2022 at 11:27 am

      Thanks so much for stopping by! I used the finest grind on the second round of the pork (that was the finest plate that comes with the KitchenAid meat grinder) and hamburger, 80/20. Have a great day!

      Reply

Trackbacks

  1. King Arthur Flour's Buttery Hot Dog Buns | The Weekday Kitchen says:
    June 30, 2020 at 5:51 pm

    […] needed some substantial buns for my Bahama Mama sausages, and I definitely wanted to go homemade (I put a lot of effort into those […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




About me

Hello, I’m Angela!
Welcome to The Weekday Kitchen, a blog to document my cooking techniques to share with my children. This is the modern equivalent of my grandmother’s handwritten recipes. They can no longer read cursive so…

Loading
wordpress com stats

theweekdaykitchen

Happy Wing Day y'all! 🍗⁠ ⁠ Honey and Black Happy Wing Day y'all! 🍗⁠ ⁠ Honey and Black Garlic Chicken Wings! So gooey and delicious! Tons of umami and a kick of Gochujang!⁠ ⁠ Right click here for recipe, or check out my linkinbio!⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/3osMBRW⁠ ⁠ #nationalchickenwingday #blackgarlic #umami #umamibomb #chickenwings #wings #delicious #spicy #friedchicken #chicken #gochujang
What is Pi? ⁠ The number π is a mathematical co What is Pi? ⁠ The number π is a mathematical constant, approximately equal to 3.14159. It is defined in Euclidean geometry as the ratio of a circle's circumference to its diameter...⁠ ⁠ apple pi, cherry pi, pecan pi, pumpkin pi, pizza pi...Whatever it is hope you're having a wonderful Pi day!! 💓⁠ ⁠ Right-click here for the easiest pie crust ever: https://bit.ly/2Wc90FK⁠ ⁠ #piday #pi #pie #happypiday #pieday #baking #instagood #foo #homemade#letthemeatpie #dessert
I feeling a bit under the weather today...time for I feeling a bit under the weather today...time for some homemade comfort food? I think so. With stock made in the @instantpotofficial this recipe is sure to bring on the comfort, while being much faster and easier. ⁠ ⁠ Recipe here⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/2VMqaN6⁠ ⁠ And all recipes and instructions can be found on my Linkinbio page!⁠ ⁠ ⁠ #comfortfood #foodi#homemade #foodstagram #yummy #delicious #homecooking #foodblogger #cooking #foodiesofinstagram #yum #soulfood #instantpotrecipes #instantpotchallenge #pressurecooker #instantpotlove #instantpotcooking #instapot #pressurecooking #instantpotmeals
We eat A LOT of guacamole. Like, a lot. Every once We eat A LOT of guacamole. Like, a lot. Every once in a while it's nice to have something just a little different and this hits the spot. 🥑🥑⁠ ⁠ Avocados, feta, tomatoes and fresh basil. It's a really amazing flavor combination, so fresh and tasty. ⁠ ⁠ Recipe here⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/3ywJzjT⁠ ⁠ And all recipes and instructions can be found on my Linkinbio page⁠ ⁠ ⁠ #avocado #food #foodie #avocadolover #foodblogger #salad #homemade #guacamole #recipe #recipes #homemade #feta
I never knew how serious Friday Fish Fry was in Wi I never knew how serious Friday Fish Fry was in Wisconsin until I moved here. It is legit serious. 🐟⁠ Every restaurant, regardless of type of restaurant, has a fish fry on Friday nights. Pizza place? Fish Fry. Supper Club? Fish Fry. Mexican joint? Fish fry. The Journal Sentinel has an article online showing “The 43 best Friday Fish Fry’s” in Milwaukee. THE FORTY THREE BEST. 😆⁠ ⁠ Of course you must make it with beer and @coorsbanquet is perfect for this recipe! ⁠ ⁠ ↔️ Swipe to see the steps...⁠ ⁠ Recipe here...⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/3rXgQlL⁠ ⁠ Tartar sauce recipe (you must try this if you love Frisch's Big Boy tartar sauce! You can't get that here, so I have to make it!)⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/3yphV8l⁠ ⁠ And all recipes and instructions can be found on my Linkinbio page!⁠ ⁠ ⁠ #fishfry #fish #seafood #foodblogger #fishing #friedfish #fishfryfriday #fishlover #homemade #dinner #firdayfishfry #coorsbanquet #banquetbeer #cookingwithbeer #beer #beerandfood #foodandbeer #tartarsauce #fishandchips
Do you like curried chicken salad? I had never had Do you like curried chicken salad? I had never had one that I liked (which is odd...I like all the things in it?? but the balance was just never quite right between the curry and the rest of the ingredients, to me. Did I ever mention that I'm picky? 🤣⁠ ⁠ So I put this one together. For me, the balance of curry, sweet and tangy turned out perfect, and it was a great dinner on a 90 degree day! Completely hit the spot. ⁠ Could it have been the Duke's Mayo? Possibly so. ⁠ @dukes_mayonnaise⁠ ⁠ Recipe here⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/3ypqiRr⁠ ⁠ And all recipes and instructions can be found on my Linkinbio page. ⁠ ⁠ ⁠ #dukes_mayonnaise #chickensalad #salad #chicken #lunch #dinner #freshfood #foodblogger #chickendinner #chickenrecipes #recipe #recipes⁠
You know how you have something at a restaurant an You know how you have something at a restaurant and you just can't find it anywhere else, and you have dreams about it, so you have to make it up yourself? ⁠ ⁠ We had the best fish tacos I've ever had in my life ⁠ @oscarsmex ...sadly we live far from San Diego so we hatched a plan to copy the smoked fish tacos. They're really amazing!! (we had been frying the fish...this is so much better! The combo of fish, pico and cabbage is out of this world). ⁠ ⁠ Used some delicious Walleye my husband caught. 🤗⁠ ⁠ So go to Oscars if you can!! Otherwise...recipe here⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/35UoC6f⁠ ⁠ And all recipes and instructions can be found on my Linkinbio!⁠ ⁠ #oscarsseafoodtacos #oscarsmexicanseafood #oscarsmex #oscarsfishtacos #smokedfish #fishtacos #recipe #foodblogger #walleye #freshfish #fishingrecipes #homemade
Sweet n sour (and spicy because that's the way we Sweet n sour (and spicy because that's the way we do in our house! 🤣) chicken meatballs⁠ ⁠ I wanted something a little more complex than sweet and sour that you get carry-out, so I added some ingredients to bang up the #umami and boy did it ever! #umamibomb ⁠ ⁠ The meatballs are par-cooked, then finished in the sauce for extra flavor. ⁠ ⁠ Recipe here⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/3xlSljl⁠ ⁠ And all recipes and instructions can be found on my Linkinbio page⁠ ⁠ #maggiseasoning #maggiusa @maggiusa #meatballs #sweetandsour #homemade #recipe #recipes #foodblogger #instafood
For years I've wanted to try making arancini but w For years I've wanted to try making arancini but was super intimidated because well...food styling just isn't something I'm super great at (I mean I'm working on it!) So I did what I do and got the right tool for the job, and soon I was cranking them out and I think they turned out *prettY* good?⁠ ⁠ And making the risotto in the Instant Pot is like a miracle, seriously. Stirring for an hour? Fuggedaboutit. 6 minutes on high and 5 minutes natural release, and BAM. ⁠ ⁠ ↔️ To see steps⁠ ⁠ Recipe and instructions here⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/3qhWaDU⁠ ⁠ And all recipes and instructions can be found on my Linkinbio page!⁠ ⁠ #arancini #foodporn #food #italianfood #sicilia #pizza #foodie #sicily #cibo #arancino #italia #sicilianfood #streetfood #arancine #ciboitaliano #delicious #homemade #arancinisiciliani #aranciniballs #buonappetito #italy #arancina #instantpotrecipes #instantpotchallenge #pressurecooker #instantpotlove #instantpotcooking #instapot #pressurecooking #instantpotmeals
You know how much I really love food that comes to You know how much I really love food that comes together fast, but every once in a while, I have to take it low and slow. ⁠ This red sauce recipe was given to me by an authentic Italian grandmother, and it came from her grandmother. The beautiful fond from browning the beef really contributes to the flavor, and the beef cooks until it nearly falls apart in the red sauce. Served with fresh homemade pasta, it's perfection! 🍝⁠ ⁠ Recipe here⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/3yiFeAv⁠ ⁠ And all recipes and instructions can be found on my Linkinbio page!⁠ ⁠ ⁠ ⁠ #pasta #food #foodporn #italianfood #foodie #instafood #pastalover #foodblogger #delicious #homemade #spaghetti #italy #italian #cooking #cucinaitaliana #healthyfood #cheese #italia #philipspastamaker #freshpasta
This is what you meant by "cheesecake" right? 🤣 This is what you meant by "cheesecake" right? 🤣🤣⁠ ⁠ It's Wisconsin, we had to ⁠ ⁠ More wedding food ideas⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/3rWfVSN⁠ ⁠ And all ideas and recipes can be found on my Linkinbio site. ⁠ ⁠ ⁠ @westallischeese @Rothcheese @cypressgrovecheese @deercreekcheese @sartoricheese⁠ ⁠ ⁠ #Rothcheese #buttermilkblue ⁠#NationalCheesecakeDay⁠ #wisconsincheese⁠ #weddingideas⁠ #humboldtfog #cypressgrovecheese⁠ #deercreekcheese⁠ #sartoricheese⁠ #weddingfood
One of my favorite Father's day gifts I've ever gi One of my favorite Father's day gifts I've ever given (really...a gift for *me* 🤣) was the Blackstone Grill. As my husband often does his first reaction was "what the heck did you do now" that rapidly turns into "this thing is awesome", and it IS. ⁠ In my opinion it's the only way to make smash burgers 🍔, (I mean you need the space, right??) and give the perfect beautiful crust on the burgers. And if you haven't tried @Dat_Ketchup with your fries, you must, because it's amazing. ⁠ ⁠ Swipe to see stages of cooking...⁠ ⁠ Blackstone grill review and some ideas on the amazing things you can cook on it. ⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/3nmFOJ7⁠ ⁠ All recipes and reviews can be found in my Linkinbio page. ⁠ ⁠ ⁠ #smashburger #burger #cheeseburger #burgers #smash #hamburguer #food #burguer #burgerlovers #smashburgers #instaburger #cheese #burgerporn #hamburguerperfeito #burgerholic #griddlenation #blackstonegriddle #blackstoneproducts @blackstoneproducts #Dat_Ketchup
Sourdough Cinnamon Raisin Bread⁠ ⁠ I guess I s Sourdough Cinnamon Raisin Bread⁠ ⁠ I guess I should call this sourdough-ish because the heavy lifting of the rise is done by commercial yeast. However, adding sourdough starter (fed or discard) and doing an overnight fermentation definitely give you the sourdough flavor, enough to balance out the sweetness of the brown sugar and raisins. Plus a double pow of vanilla with Watkins liquid and powdered vanilla. ⁠ ⁠ This is really one of our favorite breads and tastes like a warm hug 🤗⁠ ⁠ Recipe here⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/3zMGzQI⁠ ⁠ And all recipes and instructions can be found on my linkinbio page!⁠ ⁠ #sourdough #bread #sourdoughbread #levain #artisanbread #baking #realbread #bakery #homemade #wildyeast #sourdoughstarter #sourdoughbaking #breadmaking #homebaker #breadbaking #homemadebread #fermentation #watkins.1868 @watkins.1868
Muffuletta. Quite honestly the best sandwich I've Muffuletta. Quite honestly the best sandwich I've ever made. Homemade bread (They wanted like 20 dollars to ship it from NOLA. Heck to the no on that).⁠ ⁠ Homemade olive salad, and layers of Sopressata, Mortadella, Capocollo (gabba gool), Coppa and more olive salad. Wrap it tight, put a weight on top of it and refrigerate overnight. TO DIE FOR!! ⁠ ⁠ ↔️ Swipe to see delicious layers. ⁠ ⁠ Recipes here ⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/3zL2hEt⁠ ⁠ and all recipes and instructions for bread and olive salad can be found on my linkinbio page. ⁠ ⁠ #NOLAfood #sammich #muffuletta #olivesalad #gabbagool #sandwich #recipe #recipes #foodblogger #feedfeed
An updated classic, this dip has 3 kinds of onions An updated classic, this dip has 3 kinds of onions and all kinds of beefy flavor. You know how I know it's delicious? My husband said "I can't stop eating this" and had it for dessert after dinner (instead of ICE CREAM!!) Ok he's crazy 🙃⁠ ⁠ But it is really super tasty and very easy!⁠ ⁠ Recipe here⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/2VbG9nY⁠ ⁠ And all recipes and instructions can be found on my Linkinbio page!⁠ ⁠ ⁠ #appetizer #appetizers #FAGEmyway @watkins.1868 #watkins.1868 #potatochips ⁠ #delicious #yummy #tasty #recipe #recipes #foodblogger
Anatomy of a slider-⁠ In this case, Italian beef Anatomy of a slider-⁠ In this case, Italian beef sliders. The beef is cooked in beer @millerlite in the Instant Pot @instantpotofficial⁠ ⁠ That makes cooking the beef super fast and super tender. Pile it all high with cheese, a super tangy sauce, and Cento hoagie spread (if you have not tried this, it's freaking amazing. I never want a sub without it again) @centofinefoods and of course you need to serve them "dipped" (or I guess you'd say drowned in this case 🤣)⁠ ⁠ Take the time you saved on the beef and make the rolls from scratch for next-level ridiculousness. These are a huge hit at parties!⁠ ⁠ ↔️Swipe to see layers ⁠ ⁠ Recipe here⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/3BxX2cZ⁠ ⁠ and all recipes and instructions can be found on my linkinbio page⁠ ⁠ ⁠ #millerlite #beef #beefitswhatsfordinner #cookingwithbeer #beerrecipes #sliders #sandwich #recipe #recipes #foodblogger #instantpotrecipes #instantpotchallenge #pressurecooker #instantpotlove #instantpotcooking #instapot #pressurecooking #instantpotmeals
Happy #sundayfunday !! Is everybody ready for some Happy #sundayfunday !! Is everybody ready for some #brunchin this morning? ⁠ ⁠ I present to you French toast. But this isn't just regular French toast. This one is turned up to 11, with homemade sourdough-ish cinnamon raisin bread (I say ish because commercial yeast does the heavy rising, the sourdough is just for flavor). Soaking the sturdy bread in the egg mixture makes the texture somewhat of a cross between French toast and bread pudding. ⁠ ⁠ Served with Dr. Bill's Can and Maple Syrup! @drbillssyrup⁠ ⁠ Recipe here⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/3i25RUU⁠ ⁠ And all recipes and instructions can be found on my linkinbio page!⁠ ⁠ #frenchtoast #sourdough #brunch #drbillssyrup ⁠ #realbread #sourdoughbread #baking #breakfast #breadbaking #breadmaking #recipe #recipes #foodblogger
Another delicious *and* filling dinner salad. Insp Another delicious *and* filling dinner salad. Inspired by a salad I had at a restaurant which was so unique and delicious. ⁠ ⁠ The romaine is just ever so slightly grilled, and the dressing is a nice creamy and tangy horseradish flavored dressing. The three elements really pair up very nicely!⁠ ⁠ Recipe here⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/3kF2Efq⁠ ⁠ And all recipes and instructions can be found on my linkinbio page⁠ ⁠ ⁠ ⁠ #yummy #delicious #dinner #yum #eeeeeats⁠ #meat #beef #grilling #grill #meatlover #carnivore #foodpics #protein
I like having a salad *with* dinner, but it's pret I like having a salad *with* dinner, but it's pretty rare that I will have a salad *for* dinner. There just usually isn't enough there to make me feel like I've had a full meal. ⁠ That is definitely NOT the case for this Thai Chicken salad, the chicken and peanuts really give it some body. Also there's the fact that I can't stop eating it because it's so amazing. 😋😋⁠ ⁠ Prepping the chicken ahead of time really saves time on a weeknight when I'm trying to keep my crap all together!!⁠ ⁠ Recipe here⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/2UCzVgT⁠ ⁠ And all recipes and instructions can be found on my linkinbio page⁠ ⁠ ⁠ ⁠ #healthy #food #fresh #yummy #delicious #dinner #recipe #eeeeeats #veggies #foodblogger
This sous vide pork belly 🐖 🐷 with an Asian- This sous vide pork belly 🐖 🐷 with an Asian-inspired sauce turned out absolutely amazing. ⁠ ⁠ ➡️Swipe through for the process. ⁠ ⁠ The sauce has multiple ingredients that really bump up the #umamibomb flavor to 11. I cooked for 24 hours at 124 degrees Fahrenheit for the perfect silky inside texture, then seared on a hot, hot grill thanks to @vortex_cooking for the perfect crispy outside texture #maillard #maillardreaction ⁠ ⁠ Recipe here⁠ ⁠ https://bit.ly/3ixyHLI⁠ ⁠ And all recipes and instructions can be found on my Linkinbio page. ⁠ ⁠ #anovafoodnerd #vortex_cooking #umami #anova #sousvide #pork #recipe #recipes #foodblogger #gochujang #blackgarlic @kikkomanusa #kikkomanhellokitty @chami_yum #chami_yum⁠
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Copyright © 2023 · Sassafras Theme by Hello You Designs

Copyright © 2023 · Sassafras Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in